diff --git a/views/preferences.pug b/views/preferences.pug
index 252859a..6325086 100644
--- a/views/preferences.pug
+++ b/views/preferences.pug
@@ -32,7 +32,12 @@ html
           .setting
             label(for="theme") Theme: 
               select(id="theme", name="theme")
-                if(!user_preferences.theme || user_preferences.theme == '')
+                if(!user_preferences.theme || user_preferences.theme === 'auto')
+                  option(value="auto", selected="selected") Auto
+                  option(value="") White
+                  option(value="dark") Dark
+                  option(value="sepia") Sepia
+                if(user_preferences.theme == '')
                   option(value="auto") Auto
                   option(value="", selected="selected") White
                   option(value="dark") Dark
@@ -47,11 +52,6 @@ html
                   option(value="") White
                   option(value="dark") Dark
                   option(value="sepia", selected="selected") Sepia
-                if(user_preferences.theme === 'auto')
-                  option(value="auto", selected="selected") Auto
-                  option(value="") White
-                  option(value="dark") Dark
-                  option(value="sepia") Sepia
           .setting
             label(for="flairs") Show flairs: 
               if(!user_preferences.flairs || user_preferences.flairs == 'true')