Added the ability to limit video quality if using mobile data.

* Added a dropdown to video & audio settings
* Changes to ListHelper:
** Limits resolution when code requests the default video resolution
** Limits audio bitrate when code requests the default audio bitrate
** Removed some dead code and did some cleanup
** Make methods private/protected to help understand what was in use
** The code now chooses one format over an other using a simple raking system defined in array constants. I realized I needed to do this in order to choose the most efficient video stream. I did my best to evaluate the video and audio formats based on quality and efficiency. It's not an exact science.
** Made changes to the tests to support my changes
This commit is contained in:
James Straub 2018-04-21 12:35:04 -04:00
parent 7d427b4cc4
commit d1b0cd74be
7 changed files with 432 additions and 119 deletions

View File

@ -645,7 +645,7 @@ public final class MainVideoPlayer extends AppCompatActivity
@Override @Override
protected int getOverrideResolutionIndex(final List<VideoStream> sortedVideos, protected int getOverrideResolutionIndex(final List<VideoStream> sortedVideos,
final String playbackQuality) { final String playbackQuality) {
return ListHelper.getDefaultResolutionIndex(context, sortedVideos, playbackQuality); return ListHelper.getResolutionIndex(context, sortedVideos, playbackQuality);
} }
/*////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// /*//////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////

View File

@ -509,7 +509,7 @@ public final class PopupVideoPlayer extends Service {
@Override @Override
protected int getOverrideResolutionIndex(final List<VideoStream> sortedVideos, protected int getOverrideResolutionIndex(final List<VideoStream> sortedVideos,
final String playbackQuality) { final String playbackQuality) {
return ListHelper.getPopupDefaultResolutionIndex(context, sortedVideos, playbackQuality); return ListHelper.getPopupResolutionIndex(context, sortedVideos, playbackQuality);
} }
/*////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// /*//////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////

View File

@ -2,6 +2,7 @@ package org.schabi.newpipe.util;
import android.content.Context; import android.content.Context;
import android.content.SharedPreferences; import android.content.SharedPreferences;
import android.net.ConnectivityManager;
import android.preference.PreferenceManager; import android.preference.PreferenceManager;
import android.support.annotation.StringRes; import android.support.annotation.StringRes;
@ -13,56 +14,38 @@ import org.schabi.newpipe.extractor.stream.VideoStream;
import java.util.ArrayList; import java.util.ArrayList;
import java.util.Arrays; import java.util.Arrays;
import java.util.Collections; import java.util.Collections;
import java.util.Comparator;
import java.util.HashMap; import java.util.HashMap;
import java.util.List; import java.util.List;
@SuppressWarnings("WeakerAccess") @SuppressWarnings("WeakerAccess")
public final class ListHelper { public final class ListHelper {
// Video format in order of quality. 0=lowest quality, n=highest quality
private static final List<MediaFormat> VIDEO_FORMAT_QUALITY_RANKING =
Arrays.asList(MediaFormat.v3GPP, MediaFormat.WEBM, MediaFormat.MPEG_4);
// Audio format in order of quality. 0=lowest quality, n=highest quality
private static final List<MediaFormat> AUDIO_FORMAT_QUALITY_RANKING =
Arrays.asList(MediaFormat.MP3, MediaFormat.WEBMA, MediaFormat.M4A);
// Audio format in order of efficiency. 0=most efficient, n=least efficient
private static final List<MediaFormat> AUDIO_FORMAT_EFFICIENCY_RANKING =
Arrays.asList(MediaFormat.WEBMA, MediaFormat.M4A, MediaFormat.MP3);
private static final List<String> HIGH_RESOLUTION_LIST = Arrays.asList("1440p", "2160p", "1440p60", "2160p60"); private static final List<String> HIGH_RESOLUTION_LIST = Arrays.asList("1440p", "2160p", "1440p60", "2160p60");
/**
* Return the index of the default stream in the list, based on the parameters
* defaultResolution and defaultFormat
*
* @return index of the default resolution&format
*/
public static int getDefaultResolutionIndex(String defaultResolution, String bestResolutionKey, MediaFormat defaultFormat, List<VideoStream> videoStreams) {
if (videoStreams == null || videoStreams.isEmpty()) return -1;
sortStreamList(videoStreams, false);
if (defaultResolution.equals(bestResolutionKey)) {
return 0;
}
int defaultStreamIndex = getDefaultStreamIndex(defaultResolution, defaultFormat, videoStreams);
if (defaultStreamIndex == -1 && defaultResolution.contains("p60")) {
defaultStreamIndex = getDefaultStreamIndex(defaultResolution.replace("p60", "p"), defaultFormat, videoStreams);
}
// this is actually an error,
// but maybe there is really no stream fitting to the default value.
if (defaultStreamIndex == -1) return 0;
return defaultStreamIndex;
}
/** /**
* @see #getDefaultResolutionIndex(String, String, MediaFormat, List) * @see #getDefaultResolutionIndex(String, String, MediaFormat, List)
*/ */
public static int getDefaultResolutionIndex(Context context, List<VideoStream> videoStreams) { public static int getDefaultResolutionIndex(Context context, List<VideoStream> videoStreams) {
SharedPreferences defaultPreferences = PreferenceManager.getDefaultSharedPreferences(context); String defaultResolution = computeDefaultResolution(context,
if (defaultPreferences == null) return 0; R.string.default_resolution_key, R.string.default_resolution_value);
return getDefaultResolutionWithDefaultFormat(context, defaultResolution, videoStreams);
String defaultResolution = defaultPreferences.getString(context.getString(R.string.default_resolution_key), context.getString(R.string.default_resolution_value));
return getDefaultResolutionIndex(context, videoStreams, defaultResolution);
} }
/** /**
* @see #getDefaultResolutionIndex(String, String, MediaFormat, List) * @see #getDefaultResolutionIndex(String, String, MediaFormat, List)
*/ */
public static int getDefaultResolutionIndex(Context context, List<VideoStream> videoStreams, String defaultResolution) { public static int getResolutionIndex(Context context, List<VideoStream> videoStreams, String defaultResolution) {
return getDefaultResolutionWithDefaultFormat(context, defaultResolution, videoStreams); return getDefaultResolutionWithDefaultFormat(context, defaultResolution, videoStreams);
} }
@ -70,69 +53,33 @@ public final class ListHelper {
* @see #getDefaultResolutionIndex(String, String, MediaFormat, List) * @see #getDefaultResolutionIndex(String, String, MediaFormat, List)
*/ */
public static int getPopupDefaultResolutionIndex(Context context, List<VideoStream> videoStreams) { public static int getPopupDefaultResolutionIndex(Context context, List<VideoStream> videoStreams) {
SharedPreferences defaultPreferences = PreferenceManager.getDefaultSharedPreferences(context); String defaultResolution = computeDefaultResolution(context,
if (defaultPreferences == null) return 0; R.string.default_popup_resolution_key, R.string.default_popup_resolution_value);
return getDefaultResolutionWithDefaultFormat(context, defaultResolution, videoStreams);
String defaultResolution = defaultPreferences.getString(context.getString(R.string.default_popup_resolution_key), context.getString(R.string.default_popup_resolution_value));
return getPopupDefaultResolutionIndex(context, videoStreams, defaultResolution);
} }
/** /**
* @see #getDefaultResolutionIndex(String, String, MediaFormat, List) * @see #getDefaultResolutionIndex(String, String, MediaFormat, List)
*/ */
public static int getPopupDefaultResolutionIndex(Context context, List<VideoStream> videoStreams, String defaultResolution) { public static int getPopupResolutionIndex(Context context, List<VideoStream> videoStreams, String defaultResolution) {
return getDefaultResolutionWithDefaultFormat(context, defaultResolution, videoStreams); return getDefaultResolutionWithDefaultFormat(context, defaultResolution, videoStreams);
} }
public static int getDefaultAudioFormat(Context context, List<AudioStream> audioStreams) { public static int getDefaultAudioFormat(Context context, List<AudioStream> audioStreams) {
MediaFormat defaultFormat = getDefaultFormat(context, R.string.default_audio_format_key, R.string.default_audio_format_value); MediaFormat defaultFormat = getDefaultFormat(context, R.string.default_audio_format_key,
return getHighestQualityAudioIndex(defaultFormat, audioStreams); R.string.default_audio_format_value);
// If the user has chosen to limit resolution to conserve mobile data
// usage then we should also limit our audio usage.
int result;
if (isLimitingDataUsage(context)) {
result = getMostCompactAudioIndex(defaultFormat, audioStreams);
}
else {
result = getHighestQualityAudioIndex(defaultFormat, audioStreams);
} }
public static int getHighestQualityAudioIndex(List<AudioStream> audioStreams) { return result;
if (audioStreams == null || audioStreams.isEmpty()) return -1;
int highestQualityIndex = 0;
if (audioStreams.size() > 1) for (int i = 1; i < audioStreams.size(); i++) {
AudioStream audioStream = audioStreams.get(i);
if (audioStream.getAverageBitrate() >= audioStreams.get(highestQualityIndex).getAverageBitrate()) highestQualityIndex = i;
}
return highestQualityIndex;
}
/**
* Get the audio from the list with the highest bitrate
*
* @param audioStreams list the audio streams
* @return audio with highest average bitrate
*/
public static AudioStream getHighestQualityAudio(List<AudioStream> audioStreams) {
if (audioStreams == null || audioStreams.isEmpty()) return null;
return audioStreams.get(getHighestQualityAudioIndex(audioStreams));
}
/**
* Get the audio from the list with the highest bitrate
*
* @param audioStreams list the audio streams
* @return index of the audio with the highest average bitrate of the default format
*/
public static int getHighestQualityAudioIndex(MediaFormat defaultFormat, List<AudioStream> audioStreams) {
if (audioStreams == null || audioStreams.isEmpty() || defaultFormat == null) return -1;
int highestQualityIndex = -1;
for (int i = 0; i < audioStreams.size(); i++) {
AudioStream audioStream = audioStreams.get(i);
if (highestQualityIndex == -1 && audioStream.getFormat() == defaultFormat) highestQualityIndex = i;
if (highestQualityIndex != -1 && audioStream.getFormat() == defaultFormat
&& audioStream.getAverageBitrate() > audioStreams.get(highestQualityIndex).getAverageBitrate()) {
highestQualityIndex = i;
}
}
if (highestQualityIndex == -1) highestQualityIndex = getHighestQualityAudioIndex(audioStreams);
return highestQualityIndex;
} }
/** /**
@ -154,6 +101,49 @@ public final class ListHelper {
return getSortedStreamVideosList(defaultFormat, showHigherResolutions, videoStreams, videoOnlyStreams, ascendingOrder); return getSortedStreamVideosList(defaultFormat, showHigherResolutions, videoStreams, videoOnlyStreams, ascendingOrder);
} }
/*//////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
// Utils
//////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////*/
private static String computeDefaultResolution(Context context, int key, int value) {
SharedPreferences preferences = PreferenceManager.getDefaultSharedPreferences(context);
// Load the prefered resolution otherwise the best available
String resolution = preferences != null ? preferences.getString(context.getString(key),
context.getString(value)) : context.getString(R.string.best_resolution_key);
String maxResolution = getResolutionLimit(context);
if (maxResolution != null && compareVideoStreamResolution(maxResolution, resolution) < 1){
resolution = maxResolution;
}
return resolution;
}
/**
* Return the index of the default stream in the list, based on the parameters
* defaultResolution and defaultFormat
*
* @return index of the default resolution&format
*/
static int getDefaultResolutionIndex(String defaultResolution, String bestResolutionKey,
MediaFormat defaultFormat, List<VideoStream> videoStreams) {
if (videoStreams == null || videoStreams.isEmpty()) return -1;
sortStreamList(videoStreams, false);
if (defaultResolution.equals(bestResolutionKey)) {
return 0;
}
int defaultStreamIndex = getVideoStreamIndex(defaultResolution, defaultFormat, videoStreams);
// this is actually an error,
// but maybe there is really no stream fitting to the default value.
if (defaultStreamIndex == -1) {
return 0;
}
return defaultStreamIndex;
}
/** /**
* Join the two lists of video streams (video_only and normal videos), and sort them according with default format * Join the two lists of video streams (video_only and normal videos), and sort them according with default format
* chosen by the user * chosen by the user
@ -165,7 +155,7 @@ public final class ListHelper {
* @param ascendingOrder true -> smallest to greatest | false -> greatest to smallest @return the sorted list * @param ascendingOrder true -> smallest to greatest | false -> greatest to smallest @return the sorted list
* @return the sorted list * @return the sorted list
*/ */
public static List<VideoStream> getSortedStreamVideosList(MediaFormat defaultFormat, boolean showHigherResolutions, List<VideoStream> videoStreams, List<VideoStream> videoOnlyStreams, boolean ascendingOrder) { static List<VideoStream> getSortedStreamVideosList(MediaFormat defaultFormat, boolean showHigherResolutions, List<VideoStream> videoStreams, List<VideoStream> videoOnlyStreams, boolean ascendingOrder) {
ArrayList<VideoStream> retList = new ArrayList<>(); ArrayList<VideoStream> retList = new ArrayList<>();
HashMap<String, VideoStream> hashMap = new HashMap<>(); HashMap<String, VideoStream> hashMap = new HashMap<>();
@ -215,36 +205,138 @@ public final class ListHelper {
* @param videoStreams list that the sorting will be applied * @param videoStreams list that the sorting will be applied
* @param ascendingOrder true -> smallest to greatest | false -> greatest to smallest * @param ascendingOrder true -> smallest to greatest | false -> greatest to smallest
*/ */
public static void sortStreamList(List<VideoStream> videoStreams, final boolean ascendingOrder) { private static void sortStreamList(List<VideoStream> videoStreams, final boolean ascendingOrder) {
Collections.sort(videoStreams, new Comparator<VideoStream>() { Collections.sort(videoStreams, (o1, o2) -> {
@Override int result = compareVideoStreamResolution(o1, o2, VIDEO_FORMAT_QUALITY_RANKING);
public int compare(VideoStream o1, VideoStream o2) { return result == 0 ? 0 : (ascendingOrder ? result : -result);
int res1 = Integer.parseInt(o1.getResolution().replace("0p60", "1").replaceAll("[^\\d.]", ""));
int res2 = Integer.parseInt(o2.getResolution().replace("0p60", "1").replaceAll("[^\\d.]", ""));
return ascendingOrder ? res1 - res2 : res2 - res1;
}
}); });
} }
/*////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// /**
// Utils * Get the audio from the list with the highest quality. Format will be ignored if it yields
//////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////*/ * no results.
*
* @param audioStreams list the audio streams
* @return index of the audio with the highest average bitrate of the default format
*/
static int getHighestQualityAudioIndex(MediaFormat format, List<AudioStream> audioStreams) {
int result = -1;
if (audioStreams != null) {
while(result == -1) {
AudioStream prevStream = null;
for (int idx = 0; idx < audioStreams.size(); idx++) {
AudioStream stream = audioStreams.get(idx);
if ((format == null || stream.getFormat() == format) &&
(prevStream == null || compareAudioStreamBitrate(prevStream, stream,
AUDIO_FORMAT_QUALITY_RANKING) < 0)) {
prevStream = stream;
result = idx;
}
}
if (result == -1 && format == null) {
break;
}
format = null;
}
}
return result;
}
private static int getDefaultStreamIndex(String defaultResolution, MediaFormat defaultFormat, List<VideoStream> videoStreams) { /**
int defaultStreamIndex = -1; * Get the audio from the list with the lowest bitrate and efficient format. Format will be
for (int i = 0; i < videoStreams.size(); i++) { * ignored if it yields no results.
VideoStream stream = videoStreams.get(i); *
if (defaultStreamIndex == -1 && stream.getResolution().equals(defaultResolution)) defaultStreamIndex = i; * @param format The target format type or null if it doesn't matter
* @param audioStreams list the audio streams
* @return index of the audio stream that can produce the most compact results or -1 if not found.
*/
static int getMostCompactAudioIndex(MediaFormat format, List<AudioStream> audioStreams) {
int result = -1;
if (audioStreams != null) {
while(result == -1) {
AudioStream prevStream = null;
for (int idx = 0; idx < audioStreams.size(); idx++) {
AudioStream stream = audioStreams.get(idx);
if ((format == null || stream.getFormat() == format) &&
(prevStream == null || compareAudioStreamBitrate(prevStream, stream,
AUDIO_FORMAT_EFFICIENCY_RANKING) > 0)) {
prevStream = stream;
result = idx;
}
}
if (result == -1 && format == null) {
break;
}
format = null;
}
}
return result;
}
if (stream.getFormat() == defaultFormat && stream.getResolution().equals(defaultResolution)) { /**
return i; * Locates a possible match for the given resolution and format in the provided list.
* In this order:
* 1. Find a format and resolution match
* 2. Find a format and resolution match and ignore the refresh
* 3. Find a resolution match
* 4. Find a resolution match and ignore the refresh
* 5. Find a resolution just below the requested resolution and ignore the refresh
* 6. Give up
*/
static int getVideoStreamIndex(String targetResolution, MediaFormat targetFormat,
List<VideoStream> videoStreams) {
int fullMatchIndex = -1;
int fullMatchNoRefreshIndex = -1;
int resMatchOnlyIndex = -1;
int resMatchOnlyNoRefreshIndex = -1;
int lowerResMatchNoRefreshIndex = -1;
String targetResolutionNoRefresh = targetResolution.replaceAll("p\\d+$", "p");
for (int idx = 0; idx < videoStreams.size(); idx++) {
MediaFormat format = targetFormat == null ? null : videoStreams.get(idx).getFormat();
String resolution = videoStreams.get(idx).getResolution();
String resolutionNoRefresh = resolution.replaceAll("p\\d+$", "p");
if (format == targetFormat && resolution.equals(targetResolution)) {
fullMatchIndex = idx;
}
if (format == targetFormat && resolutionNoRefresh.equals(targetResolutionNoRefresh)) {
fullMatchNoRefreshIndex = idx;
}
if (resMatchOnlyIndex == -1 && resolution.equals(targetResolution)) {
resMatchOnlyIndex = idx;
}
if (resMatchOnlyNoRefreshIndex == -1 && resolutionNoRefresh.equals(targetResolutionNoRefresh)) {
resMatchOnlyNoRefreshIndex = idx;
}
if (lowerResMatchNoRefreshIndex == -1 && compareVideoStreamResolution(resolutionNoRefresh, targetResolutionNoRefresh) < 0) {
lowerResMatchNoRefreshIndex = idx;
} }
} }
return defaultStreamIndex; if (fullMatchIndex != -1) {
return fullMatchIndex;
}
if (fullMatchNoRefreshIndex != -1) {
return fullMatchNoRefreshIndex;
}
if (resMatchOnlyIndex != -1) {
return resMatchOnlyIndex;
}
if (resMatchOnlyNoRefreshIndex != -1) {
return resMatchOnlyNoRefreshIndex;
}
return lowerResMatchNoRefreshIndex;
} }
/**
* Fetches the desired resolution or returns the default if it is not found. The resolution
* will be reduced if video chocking is active.
*/
private static int getDefaultResolutionWithDefaultFormat(Context context, String defaultResolution, List<VideoStream> videoStreams) { private static int getDefaultResolutionWithDefaultFormat(Context context, String defaultResolution, List<VideoStream> videoStreams) {
MediaFormat defaultFormat = getDefaultFormat(context, R.string.default_video_format_key, R.string.default_video_format_value); MediaFormat defaultFormat = getDefaultFormat(context, R.string.default_video_format_key, R.string.default_video_format_value);
return getDefaultResolutionIndex(defaultResolution, context.getString(R.string.best_resolution_key), defaultFormat, videoStreams); return getDefaultResolutionIndex(defaultResolution, context.getString(R.string.best_resolution_key), defaultFormat, videoStreams);
@ -280,4 +372,85 @@ public final class ListHelper {
} }
return format; return format;
} }
// Compares the quality of two audio streams
private static int compareAudioStreamBitrate(AudioStream streamA, AudioStream streamB,
List<MediaFormat> formatRanking) {
if (streamA == null) {
return -1;
}
if (streamB == null) {
return 1;
}
if (streamA.getAverageBitrate() < streamB.getAverageBitrate()) {
return -1;
}
if (streamA.getAverageBitrate() > streamB.getAverageBitrate()) {
return 1;
}
// Same bitrate and format
return formatRanking.indexOf(streamA.getFormat()) - formatRanking.indexOf(streamB.getFormat());
}
private static int compareVideoStreamResolution(String r1, String r2) {
int res1 = Integer.parseInt(r1.replaceAll("0p\\d+$", "1")
.replaceAll("[^\\d.]", ""));
int res2 = Integer.parseInt(r2.replaceAll("0p\\d+$", "1")
.replaceAll("[^\\d.]", ""));
return res1 - res2;
}
// Compares the quality of two video streams.
private static int compareVideoStreamResolution(VideoStream streamA, VideoStream streamB,
List<MediaFormat> formatRanking) {
if (streamA == null) {
return -1;
}
if (streamB == null) {
return 1;
}
int resComp = compareVideoStreamResolution(streamA.getResolution(), streamB.getResolution());
if (resComp != 0) {
return resComp;
}
// Same bitrate and format
return formatRanking.indexOf(streamA.getFormat()) - formatRanking.indexOf(streamB.getFormat());
}
private static boolean isLimitingDataUsage(Context context) {
return getResolutionLimit(context) != null;
}
/**
* The maximum resolution allowed
* @param context App context
* @return maximum resolution allowed or null if there is no maximum
*/
private static String getResolutionLimit(Context context) {
String resolutionLimit = null;
if (!isWifiActive(context)) {
SharedPreferences preferences = PreferenceManager.getDefaultSharedPreferences(context);
String defValue = context.getString(R.string.limit_data_usage_none_key);
String value = preferences.getString(
context.getString(R.string.limit_mobile_data_usage_key), defValue);
resolutionLimit = value.equals(defValue) ? null : value;
}
return resolutionLimit;
}
/**
* Are we connected to wifi?
* @param context App context
* @return True if connected to wifi
*/
private static boolean isWifiActive(Context context)
{
ConnectivityManager manager = (ConnectivityManager)context.getSystemService(Context.CONNECTIVITY_SERVICE);
return manager.getActiveNetworkInfo().getType() == ConnectivityManager.TYPE_WIFI;
}
} }

View File

@ -851,4 +851,32 @@
<item>ZM</item> <item>ZM</item>
<item>ZW</item> <item>ZW</item>
</string-array> </string-array>
<!-- Limit mobile data usage -->
<string name="limit_mobile_data_usage_key" translatable="false">limit_mobile_data_usage</string>
<string name="limit_mobile_data_usage_value" translatable="false">@string/limit_data_usage_none_key</string>
<string-array name="limit_data_usage_description_list">
<item>@string/limit_data_usage_none_description</item>
<item>1080p60</item>
<item>1080p</item>
<item>720p60</item>
<item>720p</item>
<item>480p</item>
<item>360p</item>
<item>240p</item>
<item>144p</item>
</string-array>
<string-array name="limit_data_usage_values_list">
<item>@string/limit_data_usage_none_key</item>
<item>1080p60</item>
<item>1080p</item>
<item>720p60</item>
<item>720p</item>
<item>480p</item>
<item>360p</item>
<item>240p</item>
<item>144p</item>
</string-array>
<string name="limit_data_usage_none_key" translatable="false">limit_data_usage_none</string>
</resources> </resources>

View File

@ -66,6 +66,8 @@
<string name="default_video_format_title">Default video format</string> <string name="default_video_format_title">Default video format</string>
<string name="webm_description">WebM — free format</string> <string name="webm_description">WebM — free format</string>
<string name="m4a_description">M4A — better quality</string> <string name="m4a_description">M4A — better quality</string>
<string name="limit_data_usage_none_description">No limit</string>
<string name="limit_mobile_data_usage_title">Limit resolution when using mobile data</string>
<string name="theme_title">Theme</string> <string name="theme_title">Theme</string>
<string name="light_theme_title">Light</string> <string name="light_theme_title">Light</string>
<string name="dark_theme_title">Dark</string> <string name="dark_theme_title">Dark</string>

View File

@ -19,6 +19,14 @@
android:summary="%s" android:summary="%s"
android:title="@string/default_popup_resolution_title"/> android:title="@string/default_popup_resolution_title"/>
<ListPreference
android:defaultValue="@string/limit_mobile_data_usage_value"
android:entries="@array/limit_data_usage_description_list"
android:entryValues="@array/limit_data_usage_values_list"
android:key="@string/limit_mobile_data_usage_key"
android:summary="%s"
android:title="@string/limit_mobile_data_usage_title" />
<SwitchPreference <SwitchPreference
android:defaultValue="false" android:defaultValue="false"
android:key="@string/show_higher_resolutions_key" android:key="@string/show_higher_resolutions_key"
@ -39,7 +47,7 @@
android:entryValues="@array/audio_format_values_list" android:entryValues="@array/audio_format_values_list"
android:key="@string/default_audio_format_key" android:key="@string/default_audio_format_key"
android:summary="%s" android:summary="%s"
android:title="@string/default_audio_format_title"/> android:title="@string/default_audio_format_title" />
<PreferenceCategory <PreferenceCategory
android:layout="@layout/settings_category_header_layout" android:layout="@layout/settings_category_header_layout"

View File

@ -129,11 +129,6 @@ public class ListHelperTest {
assertEquals(MediaFormat.MPEG_4, result.getFormat()); assertEquals(MediaFormat.MPEG_4, result.getFormat());
} }
@Test
public void getHighestQualityAudioTest() throws Exception {
assertEquals(320, ListHelper.getHighestQualityAudio(audioStreamsTestList).average_bitrate);
}
@Test @Test
public void getHighestQualityAudioFormatTest() throws Exception { public void getHighestQualityAudioFormatTest() throws Exception {
AudioStream stream = audioStreamsTestList.get(ListHelper.getHighestQualityAudioIndex(MediaFormat.M4A, audioStreamsTestList)); AudioStream stream = audioStreamsTestList.get(ListHelper.getHighestQualityAudioIndex(MediaFormat.M4A, audioStreamsTestList));
@ -174,19 +169,20 @@ public class ListHelperTest {
new AudioStream("", MediaFormat.WEBMA, /**/ 192), new AudioStream("", MediaFormat.WEBMA, /**/ 192),
new AudioStream("", MediaFormat.M4A, /**/ 192), new AudioStream("", MediaFormat.M4A, /**/ 192),
new AudioStream("", MediaFormat.WEBMA, /**/ 192), new AudioStream("", MediaFormat.WEBMA, /**/ 192),
new AudioStream("", MediaFormat.M4A, /**/ 192))); new AudioStream("", MediaFormat.M4A, /**/ 192),
// List doesn't contains this format, it should fallback to the highest bitrate audio no matter what format it is new AudioStream("", MediaFormat.WEBMA, /**/ 192)));
// and as it have multiple with the same high value, the last one wins // List doesn't contains this format, it should fallback to the highest bitrate audio and
// the highest quality format.
stream = testList.get(ListHelper.getHighestQualityAudioIndex(MediaFormat.MP3, testList)); stream = testList.get(ListHelper.getHighestQualityAudioIndex(MediaFormat.MP3, testList));
assertEquals(192, stream.average_bitrate); assertEquals(192, stream.average_bitrate);
assertEquals(MediaFormat.M4A, stream.getFormat()); assertEquals(MediaFormat.M4A, stream.getFormat());
// Adding a new format and bitrate. Adding another stream will have no impact since
// Again with a new element // it's not a prefered format.
testList.add(new AudioStream("", MediaFormat.WEBMA, /**/ 192)); testList.add(new AudioStream("", MediaFormat.WEBMA, /**/ 192));
stream = testList.get(ListHelper.getHighestQualityAudioIndex(MediaFormat.MP3, testList)); stream = testList.get(ListHelper.getHighestQualityAudioIndex(MediaFormat.MP3, testList));
assertEquals(192, stream.average_bitrate); assertEquals(192, stream.average_bitrate);
assertEquals(MediaFormat.WEBMA, stream.getFormat()); assertEquals(MediaFormat.M4A, stream.getFormat());
} }
@Test @Test
@ -195,5 +191,111 @@ public class ListHelperTest {
assertEquals(-1, ListHelper.getHighestQualityAudioIndex(null, new ArrayList<AudioStream>())); assertEquals(-1, ListHelper.getHighestQualityAudioIndex(null, new ArrayList<AudioStream>()));
} }
@Test
public void getLowestQualityAudioFormatTest() throws Exception {
AudioStream stream = audioStreamsTestList.get(ListHelper.getMostCompactAudioIndex(MediaFormat.M4A, audioStreamsTestList));
assertEquals(128, stream.average_bitrate);
assertEquals(MediaFormat.M4A, stream.getFormat());
stream = audioStreamsTestList.get(ListHelper.getMostCompactAudioIndex(MediaFormat.WEBMA, audioStreamsTestList));
assertEquals(64, stream.average_bitrate);
assertEquals(MediaFormat.WEBMA, stream.getFormat());
stream = audioStreamsTestList.get(ListHelper.getMostCompactAudioIndex(MediaFormat.MP3, audioStreamsTestList));
assertEquals(64, stream.average_bitrate);
assertEquals(MediaFormat.MP3, stream.getFormat());
}
@Test
public void getLowestQualityAudioFormatPreferredAbsent() throws Exception {
//////////////////////////////////////////
// Doesn't contain the preferred format //
////////////////////////////////////////
List<AudioStream> testList = new ArrayList<>(Arrays.asList(
new AudioStream("", MediaFormat.M4A, /**/ 128),
new AudioStream("", MediaFormat.WEBMA, /**/ 192)));
// List doesn't contains this format, it should fallback to the most compact audio no matter what format it is.
AudioStream stream = testList.get(ListHelper.getMostCompactAudioIndex(MediaFormat.MP3, testList));
assertEquals(128, stream.average_bitrate);
assertEquals(MediaFormat.M4A, stream.getFormat());
// WEBMA is more compact than M4A
testList.add(new AudioStream("", MediaFormat.WEBMA, /**/ 128));
stream = testList.get(ListHelper.getMostCompactAudioIndex(MediaFormat.MP3, testList));
assertEquals(128, stream.average_bitrate);
assertEquals(MediaFormat.WEBMA, stream.getFormat());
////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
// Multiple not-preferred-formats and equal bitrates //
//////////////////////////////////////////////////////
testList = new ArrayList<>(Arrays.asList(
new AudioStream("", MediaFormat.WEBMA, /**/ 192),
new AudioStream("", MediaFormat.M4A, /**/ 192),
new AudioStream("", MediaFormat.WEBMA, /**/ 256),
new AudioStream("", MediaFormat.M4A, /**/ 192),
new AudioStream("", MediaFormat.WEBMA, /**/ 192),
new AudioStream("", MediaFormat.M4A, /**/ 192)));
// List doesn't contains this format, it should fallback to the most compact audio no matter what format it is.
stream = testList.get(ListHelper.getMostCompactAudioIndex(MediaFormat.MP3, testList));
assertEquals(192, stream.average_bitrate);
assertEquals(MediaFormat.WEBMA, stream.getFormat());
// Should be same as above
stream = testList.get(ListHelper.getMostCompactAudioIndex(null, testList));
assertEquals(192, stream.average_bitrate);
assertEquals(MediaFormat.WEBMA, stream.getFormat());
}
@Test
public void getLowestQualityAudioNull() throws Exception {
assertEquals(-1, ListHelper.getMostCompactAudioIndex(null, null));
assertEquals(-1, ListHelper.getMostCompactAudioIndex(null, new ArrayList<AudioStream>()));
}
@Test
public void getVideoDefaultStreamIndexCombinations() throws Exception {
List<VideoStream> testList = Arrays.asList(
new VideoStream("", MediaFormat.MPEG_4, /**/ "1080p"),
new VideoStream("", MediaFormat.MPEG_4, /**/ "720p60"),
new VideoStream("", MediaFormat.MPEG_4, /**/ "720p"),
new VideoStream("", MediaFormat.WEBM, /**/ "480p"),
new VideoStream("", MediaFormat.MPEG_4, /**/ "360p"),
new VideoStream("", MediaFormat.WEBM, /**/ "360p"),
new VideoStream("", MediaFormat.v3GPP, /**/ "240p60"),
new VideoStream("", MediaFormat.WEBM, /**/ "144p"));
// exact matches
assertEquals(1, ListHelper.getVideoStreamIndex("720p60", MediaFormat.MPEG_4, testList));
assertEquals(2, ListHelper.getVideoStreamIndex("720p", MediaFormat.MPEG_4, testList));
// match but not refresh
assertEquals(0, ListHelper.getVideoStreamIndex("1080p60", MediaFormat.MPEG_4, testList));
assertEquals(6, ListHelper.getVideoStreamIndex("240p", MediaFormat.v3GPP, testList));
// match but not format
assertEquals(1, ListHelper.getVideoStreamIndex("720p60", MediaFormat.WEBM, testList));
assertEquals(2, ListHelper.getVideoStreamIndex("720p", MediaFormat.WEBM, testList));
assertEquals(1, ListHelper.getVideoStreamIndex("720p60", null, testList));
assertEquals(2, ListHelper.getVideoStreamIndex("720p", null, testList));
// match but not format and not refresh
assertEquals(0, ListHelper.getVideoStreamIndex("1080p60", MediaFormat.WEBM, testList));
assertEquals(6, ListHelper.getVideoStreamIndex("240p", MediaFormat.WEBM, testList));
assertEquals(0, ListHelper.getVideoStreamIndex("1080p60", null, testList));
assertEquals(6, ListHelper.getVideoStreamIndex("240p", null, testList));
// match closest lower resolution
assertEquals(7, ListHelper.getVideoStreamIndex("200p", MediaFormat.WEBM, testList));
assertEquals(7, ListHelper.getVideoStreamIndex("200p60", MediaFormat.WEBM, testList));
assertEquals(7, ListHelper.getVideoStreamIndex("200p", MediaFormat.MPEG_4, testList));
assertEquals(7, ListHelper.getVideoStreamIndex("200p60", MediaFormat.MPEG_4, testList));
assertEquals(7, ListHelper.getVideoStreamIndex("200p", null, testList));
assertEquals(7, ListHelper.getVideoStreamIndex("200p60", null, testList));
// Can't find a match
assertEquals(-1, ListHelper.getVideoStreamIndex("100p", null, testList));
}
} }